Three-Bedroom Farmhouse on 5 Acres – New Holland, OH – $199,000

Property Overview

Set on 5 acres in New Holland, Ohio, this 1900 farmhouse offers 1,197 square feet of living space, three bedrooms, one full bathroom and a classic one-and-one-half-story layout. The first floor includes a bedroom, full bathroom, living room, spacious kitchen and utility room with new flooring. Two additional bedrooms are located upstairs, with one bedroom providing access through to the other.

Original hardwood floors bring historic character to the interior, complemented by vinyl flooring in selected areas. A decorative fireplace adds another period detail. The property also includes an attached one-car garage, an outbuilding and several flexible spaces that can be adapted to everyday needs.

The home is positioned along State Route 207 and is approximately two miles from the Deer Creek Marina area. The acreage provides room to enjoy the surrounding rural setting while remaining connected to the village of New Holland and the wider Deer Creek recreational area.

Interior Features

The main level combines a living room, spacious kitchen, utility room, one bedroom and one full bathroom. The utility room features new flooring, while original hardwood floors provide character throughout portions of the home. The second floor contains two additional bedrooms, with one bedroom accessed through the other.

A room adjoining the garage offers flexible space that can function as a mudroom, home office or other household-use area. At the rear of the home, another mudroom connects to a former summer kitchen, preserving another distinctive feature of the property’s history.

Exterior, Land & Parking

The property encompasses 5 acres and includes an attached one-car garage and an additional outbuilding. The acreage provides a substantial outdoor setting around the farmhouse, with multiple existing spaces and structures that contribute to the property’s rural character.

The home has no common walls and is classified as a single-family residence. The property uses a private well and private sewer system.

Property History & Tax Information

Built in 1900, the home retains architectural and functional elements associated with its long history, including the original hardwood flooring and former summer kitchen. Current property records identify the parcel as I2000010009000 in Pickaway County.

Buyer Area Research

Area Overview

New Holland is a small Ohio village located along the border of Pickaway and Fayette counties. The village describes itself as having more than 300 homes and more than 800 residents, with surrounding farmland and a location between Columbus and Chillicothe. ZIP Code 43145 is larger than the village itself and spans portions of both Pickaway and Fayette counties; the 2024 American Community Survey population estimate for the ZIP Code was 2,070.

The property itself is recorded in Pickaway County, while the New Holland community extends across the county line. This gives the area a rural agricultural setting with access to nearby communities and regional destinations.

Safety & Crime

Public safety information available for the surrounding county includes Ohio State Highway Patrol activity data. In 2023, the Ohio State Highway Patrol recorded 17,578 calls for service in Pickaway County, including 127 violence-related calls, 228 investigations and 322 crime-enforcement cases. These figures describe Ohio State Highway Patrol activity and are not a comprehensive countywide crime rate or a property-specific safety measure.

For current local information, buyers can also consult the Village of New Holland and relevant Pickaway County law-enforcement resources directly.

Schools & Education

New Holland is served by the Miami Trace Local School District. The district currently lists Miami Trace Elementary, Miami Trace Middle School and Miami Trace High School as its schools. The high school is located on Bloomingburg-New Holland Road in Washington Court House.

School proximity and district information can change, and enrollment eligibility should be confirmed directly with the district for the specific property address.

Healthcare & Hospitals

Healthcare services for the surrounding area include Adena Fayette Medical Center at 1430 Columbus Avenue in Washington Court House. The facility provides a local hospital resource, while additional medical offices and specialty providers are available in Washington Court House and surrounding communities.

Housing Market History

Historical housing data for ZIP Code 43145 provides a consistent view of median owner-occupied home values using the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey 5-year estimates. The series below uses the same geography and metric throughout.

Across this comparable series, the ZIP Code’s median home value increased from $144,800 in 2020 to $177,600 in 2024, a cumulative change of approximately 22.7%. Historical figures describe past housing conditions and are not predictions of future property values.

Transportation & Access

The property is located directly on State Route 207, providing a regional road connection through the Deer Creek area. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers information for Deer Creek Lake identifies State Route 207 as an approach to the lake and notes regional access from Interstate 71 through State Route 56 and State Route 207.

Deer Creek Lake’s marina and recreation facilities are located along the same regional corridor, providing access to boating, fishing, hiking and other outdoor activities.

Shopping & Everyday Services

Everyday shopping and pharmacy services are available in nearby Washington Court House. The community has a Kroger grocery store at 548 Clinton Avenue and a Walmart Supercenter at 1397 Leesburg Avenue. The New Holland Post Office is located at 100 North Main Street in the village.

Parks & Recreation

Deer Creek Lake is a major recreational resource near New Holland. The lake covers approximately 1,277 acres and supports boating, fishing, camping and water-based recreation. Facilities in the Deer Creek area include a marina, swimming beach, trails and day-use areas.

Deer Creek State Park also provides hiking opportunities, including designated trails around the lake. New Holland itself maintains a village park and pond area, with recent village information noting park improvements and work involving the Pickaway County Park District.

Utilities & Connectivity

The property itself is documented with private sewer, well water, propane heating and central air conditioning. These are property-specific characteristics and should be distinguished from broader area utility availability.

For internet service, current New Holland-area broadband data identifies multiple connection types, including cable, DSL, fixed wireless and satellite services. Availability can vary by exact address, so service should be confirmed with the provider before closing.

Development & Planning

Current 2026 Fayette County project information includes road, bridge, water, sewer and bike-path projects, as well as a planned single-lane roundabout at Bloomingburg-New Holland Road in Washington Court House. These county projects are regional infrastructure information and are not presented as improvements to this property.

Within New Holland, village planning information includes a current zoning map and ongoing park-related improvements. Project status and scope can change, so buyers considering the broader area should review the applicable municipal and county planning records.

Property Summary